Would you act if no one was watching? Here's a story of compassion crossing borders to...
View in browser
gwwc-logo

Hi there,

In my last email, I left you with two of the core principles behind effective giving:

  • Small amounts of money could mean the world to someone else
  • The same donation can affect one life, or many – depending on where you donate
Screenshot 2025-09-17 at 3.57.01 PM

Above: Huge variations in cost-effectiveness found across interventions. Note that this graph does not plot charities but rather interventions a charity might employ. Variations in the cost-effectiveness of charities is discussed here.

To people like our co-founder Toby, these principles were empowering and inspiring. But others have a different — and perfectly reasonable — reaction: they struggle to truly feel the difference strategic donations might make.

 

I talked last week about how it took living and working in East Africa for me to truly internalise global inequality. I met the communities our work was serving, seeing the struggles and successes firsthand. 

 

But Toby? He would never meet the people he was helping.

 

He would donate enough to save almost 50 lives (and counting!) simply by directing a portion of his modest income to effective charities each month.

 

But the people whose lives he touched? They would never know about him – and he would never see their faces.

 

It was a type of silent moral heroism that meant letting go of the need to see the results of your actions firsthand. Instead, it was about embracing a deep compassion for all living beings, whether or not you happened to have met them. 

 

This value – helping those who need help regardless of whether they are right in front of you or across the ocean – is at the heart of effective giving. It asks us to think of ourselves not only as citizens of our local area, or country, but as members of a global community. 

pexels-valentin-antonucci-1275393

What effective giving asks us to recognise is this: suffering is happening every day, even if it’s not right in front of us. And a lot of that “silent” suffering is 1) completely preventable and 2) far from silent to those who are living it. 

 

That every life has depth and meaning, whether or not we ever meet the person behind it, is the same truth at the heart of the shallow pond thought experiment — and it’s one that continues to shape how we might think about giving.

Watch the thought experiment here

(explained by its originator, Peter Singer)

Watch now

Warmly,

James

 P.S. You can give us feedback on these emails here.

Where can I find a list of the best charities?

Our research team recommends the best opportunities for donors looking to maximise the impact of their next dollar. 

See the list
GWWC-2Line-Color-Clear (4)
LinkedIn
Instagram
YouTube
Facebook
TikTok
X
Untitled design (69)

Giving What We Can

 2810 N Church St, PMB 52576, Wilmington, Delaware, 19802-4447, USA

 

Want to change which emails you receive?
View and update your subscription preferences here!

Or unsubscribe from all Giving What We Can emails.